There are three main ways to run an online store: rent a ready-made one from Shopify, add WooCommerce to a WordPress site you host, or have one built for you. Shopify vs WooCommerce is the usual question, but a custom-built store belongs in the comparison too. This guide compares all three on cost, ease of use, speed, SEO, payments and ownership, and says who each one fits.
The short answer: most small businesses should start on Shopify or WooCommerce. A custom store makes sense when the way you sell fits neither, and you can pay to build it and maintain it.
How each one works
- Shopify is a hosted service. You pay a monthly fee, and Shopify runs the servers, the software and the checkout. You add features with apps.
- WooCommerce is a free, open-source plugin that turns a WordPress site into a store. You pay for hosting, and you or your developer keep WordPress, the theme and the plugins up to date.
- A custom-built store is designed and coded for your business, and connects to a payment provider such as Stripe. It can do anything you need, but every feature has to be built, tested and maintained.
What each one costs to start and run
Compare five types of cost, added up over two or three years, not just the first month.
- Plan or platform fee. Shopify charges a monthly plan fee. The main plans are Basic, Grow and Advanced, with Plus for large businesses. Paying yearly costs less. WooCommerce is free and takes no share of your sales. A custom store has no platform fee: you pay for the build instead.
- Payment fees. Every store pays a fee on each card payment. With Shopify Payments, the rate depends on your plan. With another provider, Shopify adds its own transaction fee on top: 2% on Basic, 1% on Grow and 0.6% on Advanced. WooCommerce and custom stores pay only the payment provider.
- Hosting. Every Shopify plan includes hosting and an SSL certificate. For WooCommerce or a custom store, you pay a host, and the bill grows with traffic. WooCommerce's pricing page puts hosting for most stores at $25 to $350 a month.
- Apps, plugins and themes. Shopify apps often have their own subscription, billed separately from your plan. Paid WooCommerce extensions cost $29 to $299 a year each, according to WooCommerce. Both have free and paid themes. On a custom store, features cost development time instead.
- Developer time. Shopify needs the least to launch. WooCommerce needs more setup and regular maintenance. A custom store needs the most, both to build and to keep running.
Prices differ between the US and the UK and change over time, so check Shopify's pricing page and WooCommerce's pricing page for current figures.
Ease of use and design freedom
- Shopify is usually the easiest to run yourself. Products, orders and the theme are managed in one admin, there is no server to look after, and support is available 24/7. You can change almost anything in the theme, but full checkout customisation is only on Plus.
- WooCommerce uses the WordPress admin, which many people already know. Because the code is open, a developer can change anything, including the checkout. The cost of that freedom is upkeep: updates, backups and security are your job, or your developer's.
- A custom store can look and work exactly as you want, but its admin is only as easy as it is built to be, so ask to see it early.
Speed and SEO
Any of the three can rank well. What matters is a fast site, useful pages and sound technical SEO.
- Shopify hosts stores on global servers with a CDN, and creates sitemaps and canonical tags for you. What slows a store down is mostly the theme, the apps and extra tracking code. Shopify itself warns that too many apps can slow your storefront.
- WooCommerce is as fast as your hosting, theme and plugins allow. Caching helps a lot, but the cart, checkout and account pages must stay out of the cache. You control URLs and SEO settings, usually through an SEO plugin.
- A custom store can be the fastest of the three, because it carries no code you don't use. But SEO basics such as sitemaps, structured data and redirects must be built in, so put them in the brief.
Busy days and growth
- Shopify handles traffic for you, and load-tests its platform before Black Friday. Bigger plans bring lower card rates and more staff accounts: none extra on Basic, 5 on Grow and 15 on Advanced. Plus adds a checkout built for very high volumes.
- WooCommerce can run busy stores, but capacity depends on your hosting. Before a big sale, ask your host what your plan can take. Since version 8.2, new stores keep orders in their own database tables, which helps as orders build up.
- A custom store scales as far as it is designed to. Cloud hosting can grow with demand, but someone has to plan it, test it under load and pay for it.
Payments and selling abroad
- Shopify: Shopify Payments works in the US and the UK and avoids the extra transaction fee. PayPal is exempt too when Shopify Payments is your main provider. Every plan includes Shopify Markets, for local currencies, translated storefronts, local domains and duty estimates. Local currencies need Shopify Payments and carry a conversion fee: 1.5% for US stores and 2% for UK stores.
- WooCommerce: WooPayments, built with Stripe, has no setup or monthly fee, works in 38 countries including the US and the UK, and handles multiple currencies. You can also use Stripe, PayPal or another gateway, and WooCommerce adds no fee of its own. Extra languages and per-country tax rules take more setup, and often paid extensions.
- A custom store uses whichever provider you choose. Stripe, for example, has no monthly fee, charges per payment and adds fees for international cards and currency conversion. Taxes, currencies and languages are yours to build or connect.
Ownership and moving later
- Shopify: you rent the platform. Products, customers, orders and discount codes export as CSV files, but apps and settings don't move with you, and the theme only runs on Shopify.
- WooCommerce: WordPress and WooCommerce are open source, so the files and database are yours to take to any host or developer. Check that paid extension licences are in your business's name.
- A custom store: you can own the code as well as the data. Get that in writing in your contract, and keep the code in a repository you control, so another developer could take over.
Which one fits your business?
Choose Shopify when
- You want to launch quickly and run the store yourself.
- You'd rather not manage hosting, updates or security.
- Your products and checkout are fairly standard, and apps cover the extras.
- You expect busy peaks, such as Black Friday, and don't want to think about servers.
Choose WooCommerce when
- You already run WordPress, or content such as guides matters as much as the shop.
- You want to own the code and data and choose your own host and payment provider.
- You need more control over the checkout or URLs than Shopify gives you.
- Someone will look after it: updates, backups and security, every month.
Choose a custom store when
- The way you sell doesn't fit a platform: quotes, product builders, trade pricing or rules no app handles well.
- The store must work closely with your systems, such as stock, production or an ERP.
- Platform and app fees at your volume would cost more than building and running your own.
- You can budget for years of maintenance, not just the launch.
Just starting, or testing a product? Pick the simplest option that works, and move up once you know what the store must do.
The middle path: Shopify or WooCommerce with custom parts
You don't have to choose between off-the-shelf and fully custom. Many stores do best on a platform, with custom work only where it counts:
- A custom theme designed around your brand and products.
- A custom app or plugin for the one feature nothing ready-made covers, such as a product builder or a link to your stock system.
- Headless Shopify: Shopify runs products, checkout and payments, and a custom-built front end handles the design. Every plan includes at least one headless storefront.
For help with each route, see our Shopify development, WordPress development (for WooCommerce) and custom web development pages.
Talk to Devtings
Devtings builds Shopify stores, WordPress sites and custom web applications for small and mid-size businesses in the US and the UK. Tell us how you sell, and we'll say which option fits, even when it's the simplest one. See our Shopify development services or get in touch.

